When Keisha Buchanan got booted out of the Sugagbabes, loads of people thought it would be a great idea for her to reform the original lineup with Mutya and Siobhan. Well, that's exactly what is happening. *dramatic pause* TODAY.

Even as I type the three are in a second meeting with a potential producer (thought to be William Orbit or Stuart Price) and their label (thought to be Warners).

The label are keen for them to work with Orbit, but Siobhan is said to be reluctant.

On top of the new group deal, all three have been offered seperate solo deals as a bit of a sweetener.

This is pretty ace news for them (They were fucking great) but dreadful news for the current Sugababes, who can't seem to organise a piss up in a brewery at the moment.

Hurray to them!

source: http://08137edc.linkbucks.com/url/http://w...-reforming40299

just a rumour?

OMG :blink: :blink: :blink: Yes yes yes! Let be true!!!!!!

OMG that would be f*cking in heaven!

Stuart Price <3
William Orbit <3
Sugababes 1.0 <3

Please NO.

//

It's not true btw, http://bit.ly/4NoPL

YES!! i really hope so ! :P

To good to be true!

WTF why not?
They have more talent individually than the current ones put together, sorry to say...

I really hope this is true but I struggle to believe it. :(

I would be so thrilled if they got back togethe. Stuart Price and William Orbit are my top producers too. This just seems to good to be true.

Supposed this is true, would they get a new name?

They would have to. Also I don't think they would be able to sing any of their old hits either.

so want this to be true
be back and forward to keishas twitter all night could be a late one

I remember how Keisha on her twitter said she's NOT about to reform the original Sugababes line-up ... so how can this be true?

LOL! What a whole bunch of crap that is, I can see Mutya and Keisha possibly in the future but Siobhan? :ph43r:

They'd have to use a different name, but considering they have writing credits on most of the previous material - they have every right to perform it. More so than "Sug4babes" anyways...

I've asked Mutya's manager about it and something is definitely happening, a close friend of Siobhan has also confirmed the same.

THIS IS TOO EXCITING :D

Well at least Mutya and Siobhan have finally realised they don't have and never will have what it takes to be a solo success if this is true LOL. I think Keisha could've done well though. I never supported V1 and I sure as Hell won't be starting now. V4 for the fucking win.

Well if being successful means showing your tits in your music videos, I'd rather have them as less known, underground artists who have actual integrity.

And you can carry on being fed all this bullshit by the joke that "Sugababes" have become. They don't even respect what's left of their fans anymore. It's very sad really.

Also, Siobhan has more talent in her left toenail than Heidi, Jade & Amelle combined. I could say the same about Mutya, but everyone will say I'm biased about that.

Ok my dear, how about you have your opinion and I have mine? There's so so SO much I could say about what you've said but I respect what you have to say and don't feel the need to attack it. Anyway I have said what I have to say on this so-called wonderful news. I hope you all get what you want.

Fine by me. I never said you shouldn't have a different opinion. I was simply expressing mine.

I will be def supporting V.1. if they re-formed.
I'm still sceptical about Siobhan though. She has so much hatred for Keisha especially in that recent interview she did. I just don't see Siobhan forgiving Keisha.

I'd rather solo albums from Keisha and Siobhan.

It reeks of desperation to me.

Yeah Amelle is showing her tits in their new music video and Mutya is promoting her new tits and new ass on TV. At least Amelle didn't do it on purpose.:rolleyes:

Well back on topic.
I can't really believe this. Didn't Keisha that all these rumours are false ? And I can't imagine Keisha and Siobhan back together. Besides Keisha has already started writing her solo material.

And why is everyone so excited about this reforming? They were never succesfull with the Siobhan, Mutya and Keisha line-up.

I know it's hard to believe, but some artists are more about the quality of the music than the sales. The original Sugababes line-up was like that.

One of the best things i've read on this forum in days.
Couldnt agree more.

I agree with that, but on the other side it was you Kal who said several times after Mutya left that the upcoming post-Mutya album will flop. In this case you also were about the sales weren't you ?

Which is why they were dropped.

Face it, the public don't care about the quality of music anymore. If they did artists like Siobhan would do well.

This is the reason why people like Cheryl Cole are doing well.

Thats why I was totally into them from day 1.
That was what make them different from the rest of the girlbands and Pop acts of the time. Doing credible and fun music without the flesh showing.

When the "Taller" promo started and then later when Amelle joined it all went downhill on that theme... a weak Poppy album, then a boring "look at us, we still do credible music" album and now... oh well. :ph43r:

Thats why I keep saying, it'll be all about sales and sexiness now. No more good credible music from them. Keisha was the one who was still trying to hold that on the band. Now kill me.

Nitpicking much? I don't even remember, but I probably said I hope it would flop.

And what's my take on things have to do with the fact Sugababes v1 were about the music while from v3 onward we're getting more and more sex.

Sugababes v.1: Make music they like, and hope it sells.

v.2 were more commercial but they still did what they liked, not what was hot at the moment, and it still had that Sugababes sound...

I know many of you love Amelle, fair enough, but ever since she joined the b®and all they've been doing is jumping on bandwagons and working with the "HOTTEST" producers. Some of their output was indeed very good (C&S) but they kinda lost their identity.

Let me get this straight, if THE REAL SUGABABES are indeed reforming I couldn't care less if they sell by the bucketloads or not. I obviously want them to be successful, because it's nice to get recognition, but it's not the most important thing for me.

But I refuse to conform to this. And so should other people. The music industry can't be this doomed, can it? There is still hope...

Just because I seem to have a better memory I'm not nitpicking.

It still has zero relevance to the topic about Sugababes v1 being about the music, not the face or the money.

As long as people like Cheryl Cole and The Saturdays do well then no there's no hope.

Hmm.. but there will always be the more underground acts, which, like Siobhan, make brilliant music and go unrecognized.

I just find it really sad that the charts are dominated by the same kind of sound and producers. No one dares to experiment and be interesting anymore.

But yeah.. Sugababes v1...

I'm sorry, you know i love you Luke
But its not right that you should say that about Cheryl and the Sats
when you admire Britney Spears, She's the DEFINITION.
I dont want to turn this into a britney bashing, shes got her positives
but shes as bad, if not worse, as those your accusing.
Its just the principle.

They have BRILLIANT tracks given to them
And that's how they get by

Somtimes i wander whats right
Should a singer just sing, and writers and producers make the music
in that respect theyre both doing their thing
the singers a vessel for the creator of the song, that seems right to me
But its seen as the right thing if singers get involved
i can see how thats important, but its blurred the line
Even though i prefer this method.

What would everyone say is the right way?
if even just the one atall.

I actually included Britney when I orginally wrote that post saying that if the public cared about the quality of music Christina would be doing much better than Britney at the moment. But because who Britney is and the tracks she's given she does well.

Deleted that comment though as I felt bad posting it! lol

Nuhu, dont feel bad haha! its true
I dont think its so much a dig at the artist
they both just represent completely opposite things in the industry

I personally don't care about the artist's input into a song. As long as the song itself is good that's all that matters.

I like input into the song itself
though i could leave it
i mainly look for input into everything else
the videos, the shoots, all of that.
a real involvement and general passion for it.
Dare i say it, but i think Lady Gaga has everything balanced perfectly.

We heard somthing very similar to this a few weeks back and t built up a snowball which turned into nothing but a press rumor.

It is an exciting idea and the prospect of it sounds intreeging but until we hear somthing offical - one of them actually coming out and stating it publically all it is, is a rumor from a journlist making up a story.

However as we have seen in the past these things can become bigger and just for once somthing positive seems to have emerged from all this - so I do hope we hear more about this as resulting to chuking it all in the fire like last time so to speak.

How they would actually fair though is a different matter - some combacks fail some succeed.

From DigitalSpy

I love how they twist the headline to make it more 'exciting'.

All Warner denied is that they approached the girls. No one said if they aren't really getting back together.