Im gunna Include Mutya hear, since its not that long since she departed...............
I think eiether Mutya or Amelle
Keisha can sometimes sound a little jittery and all over the place and i realy dont mean to be horrile, but heidi is awful... i dont even really think she can sing that well..
Im gunna go amelle based on all the performances ive seen of her so far, shes been great on all occasions, although Mutya is also great.

I Would Say Keisha

1. Keisha (I think she´s the best)

2. Amelle, Mutya
3. Heidi

Mutya for sure

Keisha, if it werent for her voice her mood(i/y)ness would push me over the edge....

>_>_>_>_
................| \/
................| \/
................| \/
................| \/
..................=[

xx

Heidi....and maybe Mutya :mutya: :heidi:

Mutya

I never heard them sing live coz i reside in Canada but based on some of the performances that Ive seen at youtube it would be;
:keisha: :mutya: (it goes back and forth) but I really fillin keisha at the moment
:heidi: and than amelle (i dont like her pronounciation on some songs)

Even if Heidi's my favourite I think Mutya has the best voice of them.

Same here.

Heidi ofcourse

I voted for Keisha because I like her voice.

Mutya of course. She sings so powerfully and her voice is just so unique. She actually sounds better live than on record. And she sings so laidback and relaxed. Even when all three of them sing together, Mutya's voice is dominant.

Heidi is second. Sometimes she sings in an amazing way and so beautiful, but most of the time she sings so quietly I can barely hear her.

Amelle is third, 'cos I like the uniqueness in her voice and her sexy accent. "Cooler than the red dress.. Cos Im cooler.. Cooler"

I HATE KEISHA. She can't control her voice. It goes low then suddenly goes really high-pitched and when she sings live her voice is shaking like she's trying so hard to be perfect and it ends up sounding crap. She doesn't know how to keep her voice in an even tune and it sounds like she's singing all over the place.. Horrible. <_<

Heidis is ma fave voice...but live i do kinda agree that she sometimes has problems...but u normally find that if one of them have probs then they all do

I do agree that mutya has an amazin voice but then sometimes i think that her live voice can be flat and boring and cuz its not high like heidi and keisha u dont notice the flaws she makes as bad

so live my favourite would actually have to be Amelle...shockingly cuz i think she can control her performances really well....then its a toss up between heidi and mutya

I think Mutya has the best live voice. It's only then when I noticed that her live voice is even better than that on the CD..even if she had 1 or 2 flaws they just fit in and when I heard Follow me home live @ GAY there was no other. Second would have to be Keisha..she always hits the notes then followed by Amelle.

Heidi is great on CD but quite bland live.

I`ve never actually seen Mutya live, accept on performances I`ve downloaded - she sounds pretty good on them though. Since the tour, I think Heidi has a really strong singing voice live, and thst`s probably because she stopped smoking - because, I hate to say it, she was pretty bad at singing live before.. well sometimes. I think Keisha overdoes her performances sometimes, but maybe that`s just what she likes doing. She is great singing live. I don`t think Amelle is so good live, but maybe it`s because it was her first time doing something like that infront of thousands of people. So - I have to go with Keisha.

its gotta be mutya

Clearly Mutya.
But Out Of This Line-Up..
Keisha

Out of all 5 Sugababes Mutya has the best voice, she sounds AMAZING recorded but live she pulls it off even better. LOVE her! :D

Pretty Sure We Know What You Think Of Her. . .
B) :rolleyes: :lol:

I'm so right though ;) She's always spot on!

Well yes sir, I couldn't agree more!
Speshly On Buster :wub: