View Full Version: What Would You Do???

Rate The Ref > Whistleblower > What Would You Do???



Title: What Would You Do???


Mackem ref - October 31, 2007 05:05 PM (GMT)
What would you do in the following situations??:

1) Under 13's encounter. Red 2 jumps in with a two footed challenge on blue 7. after this blue 7 proceeds to shove red 2 to the ground.


2) Under 12's game. Orange 3 handles the ball on the line.

3) Under 14's clash. After a poor challenge by Green 4, you go to caution him. While you are busy cautioning him, White 10 shouts some choice words to you(Possibly abusive)


davet - October 31, 2007 05:09 PM (GMT)
1) Under 13's encounter. Red 2 jumps in with a two footed challenge on blue 7. after this blue 7 proceeds to shove red 2 to the ground.

Red card to Red 2 - Blue 7 caution assuming shove has nothing else attached to it.


2) Under 12's game. Orange 3 handles the ball on the line.

Red card to Orange 3

3) Under 14's clash. After a poor challenge by Green 4, you go to caution him. While you are busy cautioning him, White 10 shouts some choice words to you(Possibly abusive)

Finish caution and dismiss White 10 for abusive language.


Yes, I am a stickler, but if you don't teach them, they will never learn.

exeter_ref - October 31, 2007 05:11 PM (GMT)
1) Under 13's encounter. Red 2 jumps in with a two footed challenge on blue 7. after this blue 7 proceeds to shove red 2 to the ground.

[B]Dismiss Red 2. Possibly blue 7 follows but you have to be there really. Depends on force, where contact is made and how much etc.

2) Under 12's game. Orange 3 handles the ball on the line.
Deliberately? If yes, sending off. Handle in a careful manner for age, but send off.

3) Under 14's clash. After a poor challenge by Green 4, you go to caution him. While you are busy cautioning him, White 10 shouts some choice words to you(Possibly abusive)

If I find it insulting, offensive or abusive, he walks. Otherwise deal with as appropriate, preferably after this caution is done.

Tess La Fyn - October 31, 2007 05:13 PM (GMT)
1) Red card to both. First challenge is SFP, second is VC!

2) Red card, DOGSO, even at that age they know whats what!

3) Caution for challenge, assuming it was poor rather than DANGEROUS; Red card for the OFFINABUS!

costy1190 - October 31, 2007 09:52 PM (GMT)
Well, age has no impact on the laws of the game so...

1) Under 13's encounter. Red 2 jumps in with a two footed challenge on blue 7. after this blue 7 proceeds to shove red 2 to the ground.

Red card to red 2. Depending on the shove a yellow or red to blue 7, leaning mroe towards yellow to be honest.


2) Under 12's game. Orange 3 handles the ball on the line.

Red Card - assuming it's his own goal line of course.

3) Under 14's clash. After a poor challenge by Green 4, you go to caution him. While you are busy cautioning him, White 10 shouts some choice words to you(Possibly abusive)

Continue with the caution.

Dissmiss white 10 if i saw the 'chpice words' as abusive, insulting or offensive. Otherwise caution him for dissent.

flipmode - October 31, 2007 11:56 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (Mackem ref @ Oct 31 2007, 18:05 PM)
What would you do in the following situations??:

1) Under 13's encounter. Red 2 jumps in with a two footed challenge on blue 7. after this blue 7 proceeds to shove red 2 to the ground.


2) Under 12's game. Orange 3 handles the ball on the line.

3) Under 14's clash. After a poor challenge by Green 4, you go to caution him. While you are busy cautioning him, White 10 shouts some choice words to you(Possibly abusive)

1. Red 2 would be walking for an early bath, and depending on the severity of the push (by word tone,I'm guessing it is hard?) he follows him. A few minutes in between though so they don't renew their friendship off the FOP.

2. Walking for DOGSO

3. RC, the cheeky little so and so needs to be taught a lesson. Under 14 :o

Ooooh I'm so harsh :lol:

crispy - November 1, 2007 07:48 AM (GMT)
Agree with above. They have to learn, I might allow an extra couple of fouls for PI, etc - but no choice on RC offences I'm afraid.

mac - November 1, 2007 04:13 PM (GMT)
1) I'd need to view the challenge and subsequent reaction in a game situation. But we're at least looking at a caution each depending on how forceful the shove was and how much man to ball ratio was involved in the tackle

2) Easy peasy. Sadly it's a red card assuming the handling offence was deliberate in the opinion of the referee and the ball hadn't crossed the line already (hint hint).

3) How the heck do I know what choice words involves? I might tell him to shut his trap (either in that form or otherwise), caution him or send him off depending on what he said, how he said it, whether it was instinctive or wilful etc etc.

nemesis - November 1, 2007 11:58 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (Mackem ref @ Oct 31 2007, 17:05 PM)
What would you do in the following situations??:

1)  Under 13's encounter. Red 2 jumps in with a two footed challenge on blue 7. after this blue 7 proceeds to shove red 2 to the ground.


2) Under 12's game. Orange 3 handles the ball on the line.

3) Under 14's clash. After a poor challenge by Green 4, you go to caution him. While you are busy cautioning him, White 10 shouts some choice words to you(Possibly abusive)


Not sure the ages are relevant.

1. Either two yellows, two reds or a combination of a yellow and a red either way depending on what actually happened. Not enough information to be prescriptive.

2. If it was deliberate, the ball was going to go in and not hit a post, and, most importantly, Orange was a defender, it's a red card. Explore all options for it not being so first.

3. First of all I would decide if the words were abusive. If you say possibly abusive, it suggests maybe you didn't hear the words in which case the tone and manner might be enough for a YC for dissent. I might wonder why he is abusing me for cautioning an opponent? If he's telling me I should be sending off the opponent, again possibly a YC. If, perversely, he is telling me I shouldn't be cautioning an opponent I might let it go with a quiet (or not so quiet) word.

cstobart - November 27, 2007 10:57 PM (GMT)
1) Under 13's encounter. Red 2 jumps in with a two footed challenge on blue 7. after this blue 7 proceeds to shove red 2 to the ground.
Red2 red for dangerous play, blue7 red for gross miss conduct, free kick awareded to blues.


2) Under 12's game. Orange 3 handles the ball on the line.
Orange 3 red for denying an abvouse goal scoring oppertunity

3) Under 14's clash. After a poor challenge by Green 4, you go to caution him. While you are busy cautioning him, White 10 shouts some choice words to you(Possibly abusive)
White 10, nothing. if you gave him/her a red you cant be sure they did swear.

TheThingFromLewes - November 28, 2007 10:58 PM (GMT)
Ask Rob Styles... mind you he'd probably send the lot off! :oops:

jofusref - November 29, 2007 12:15 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (davet @ Oct 31 2007, 17:09 PM)
1) Under 13's encounter. Red 2 jumps in with a two footed challenge on blue 7. after this blue 7 proceeds to shove red 2 to the ground.

Red card to Red 2 - Blue 7 caution assuming shove has nothing else attached to it.


2) Under 12's game. Orange 3 handles the ball on the line.

Red card to Orange 3

3) Under 14's clash. After a poor challenge by Green 4, you go to caution him. While you are busy cautioning him, White 10 shouts some choice words to you(Possibly abusive)

Finish caution and dismiss White 10 for abusive language.


Yes, I am a stickler, but if you don't teach them, they will never learn.

i agree age is erelevant




Hosted for free by InvisionFree