Hmmm....wasnt there one of these before. I coulda sworn i done some tests that proved the other way around...
| QUOTE ("Silas") |
Ok, lets do some tests shall we? Taking into account that Snikch is over 100pts more then Shadowblade I removed the shooting part. Actually it was because i couldnt be bothered with that malarky...
There's no point in Snikch's Bands of Power since he wounds Shadowblade on 2's with or without it, being Str5 and all...
Test 1; Snikch Charges no Potion of Strengh;
He strikes first with 4 attacks. Wait, its 3 attakcs due to Shadowblades Hand of Khaine skill. However Snikch adds 2 attacks due to using 3 Weeping Blades in his tail. 5 attacks hitting on 4's; 2 hits. Wounding on 2's; 2 wounds.
Shadowblade saves on 5+; 1 wound caused. Weeping Blades mean; 2 wounds in total. Shadowblade lives!
Shadowblade attacks; 7 attacks hitting on 3's; causing 5 hits, 2 of which are poisoned. 2 auto wounds. Wounding on 4's adds another 2 to the wounds; 4 for Snikch to save. 4+ save. oooh, he fails 3. Snikch dies.
Test 2, Sniktch Charges no Potion of Strengh (take 2 out of 3)
Again 5 attacks, causing 3 hits this time. 3 wounds. Shadowblade saves 1 and suffers 2d3 wounds. He's dead. He explodes causing no wounds to Sniktch.
Test 3; Sniktch Charges no Potion of Strengh (take 3 out of 3)
Again 5 attack, this time only 2 hits causing 2 wounds. Shadowblade saves one suffering d3 wounds. He takes 2.
Shadowblade attacks; 4 hits, one auto wounding. Another 2 wounds, one with killing blow. Snikch fails to save the killing blow and dies.
Test 4; Snikch charges, Potion of Strengh used;
5 attacks, 3 hits, 3 wounds, 2 saves, Shadowblade suffers 2 wounds.
7 attacks; 6 hits, 1 autowound, 4 more wounds, 2 saves, Snikch dead.
Test 5; Snikch charges, Potion of Strengh used (take 2 out of 3);
5 attacks, 2 hits, 2 wounds, 2 saves.
7 attacks, 5 hits, 1 autowound, 2 more wounds, 1 killing blow. Saves killing blow, fails to save the others. Snikch dead.
Test 6; Snikch charges, Potion of Strengh used (take 3 out of 3);
5 attacks, 5 hits, 4 wounds, 1 save, Shadowblade dead.
Test 7; Shadowblade charges, no Potion of Strengh used;
7 attacks; 6 hits, 2 autowounds, another 1 wound, Snikch saves 2
5 attacks; 2 hits, 2 wounds, Shadowblade fails both, suffers 4 wounds and dies, dealing Snikch another wound.
Test 8; Shadowblade charges, no Potion of Strengh used (2 out of 3);
7 attacks, 4 hits, 2 killing blows, Snikch dies
Test 9; Shadowblade charges, no Potion of Strengh used (3 out of 3);
7 attacks, 6 hits, 1 autowound, 1 killingblow, 2 more wounds, Snikch dies (although he saves the killing blow...)
Test 10; Shadowblade charges, Potion of Strengh used;
7 attacks, 5 hits, 2 autowounds, 1 killing blow, 2 more wounds, Snikch saves killing blow and one other. Snikch dies.
Test 11; Shadowblade charges, Potion of Strengh used (2 out of 3);
7 attacks, 6 hits, 1 autowound, 5 more wounds, Snikch saves 3; Snikch dies.
Test 12; Shadowblade charges,Potion of Strengh used (3 out of 3);
7 attacks, 4 hits, 1 killing blow, 1 more wound, Snikch saves both.
5 attacks, 3 hits, 2 wounds, 1 save, suffers 3 wounds; Shadowblade dies.
Test 13; Strike Simultaneously, no Potion of Strengh;
7 attacks, 5 hits, 1 autowound, 2 more wounds, Snikch saves 2.
5 attacks, 3 hits, 3 wounds, 1 save, shadowblade suffers 4 wounds and dies.
Explosion causes a wound to Snikch who also dies.
Test 14; Strike Simultaneously, no Potion of Strengh (2 out of 3);
7 attacks, 7 hits, 2 killing blows, 2 more wounds, Snikch fails one killing blow (saves the rest though) and dies.
5 attacks, 3 hits, 3 wounds, Shadowblade dies.
Test 15; Strike Simultaneously, no Potion of Strengh (3 out of 3);
7 attacks, 3 hits, 1 killing blow. Snikch lives.
5 attacks, 2 hits, 2 wounds, 1 save, shadowblade suffers 2 wounds
7 attacks, 5 hits, 1 killing blow, 2 more wounds, Snikch suffers 2 wounds.
5 attacks, 1 hit, 1 wound, shadowblade dies.
Explosion kills Snikch
Test 16; Strike Simultaneously, Potion of Strengh used;
7 attacks, 6 hits, 1 killing blow, 5 more wounds, Snikch saves 3 and dies
5 attacks, 3 hits, 2 wounds. 1 save, 2 wounds dealt to shadowblade
Test 17; Strike Simultaneously, Potion of Strengh (2 out of 3);
7 attacks, 5 hits, 5 wounds, Snikch dies
5 attacks, 2 hits, 2 wounds, Shadowblade dies
Test 18; Strike Simultaneously, Potion of Strengh (3 out of 3);
7 attacks, 5 hits, 1 killing blow, 3 more wounds, Snikch suffers 2 wounds
5 attacks, 3 hits, 2 wounds, 1 save, Shadowblade suffers 1 wound
7 attacks, 3 hits, 2 autowounds, 1 killing blow, Snikch dies
5 attacks, 2 hits, 1 wound, 1 save. Shadowblade lives!
In total;
Shadowblade wins 10,
Snikch kills 4
They kill each other 4 times.
I'm not saying this is fool proof since alot of luck is envolved here. For instance Snikch never once got a killing blow against Shadowblade, whereas Shadowblade got loads against him. Admitedly because Shadowblade has more attacks that is more likely there is still the chance that Snikch would get it. This is a fairly good start to testing who would win, but for it to be really clear you'd need at least 100 tests, preferably more.
Still, I think Shadowblade wins here... |
|