View Full Version: Carmac Or Carguy?

Green Wing Fan Forum > 'Ships! > Carmac Or Carguy?

Pages: [1] 2 3


Title: Carmac Or Carguy?
Description: for those who are torn...


Lollapalooza - May 22, 2006 06:58 PM (GMT)
LIKE ME


i really really dont know


I always thought i was a true CarMacer but then Guy seesm to truely love Caroline.



oooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh


:bangh

xpingux - May 22, 2006 06:59 PM (GMT)
CarMac obviously!

Lollapalooza - May 22, 2006 07:00 PM (GMT)
shush shush


this is just for those who genuinely dont know



so that'll probably just be me then

:)

m+cshipper - May 22, 2006 07:08 PM (GMT)
you must choose a side Young Skywalker!! It is either The Force, or the Dark Side (aka Guy and Caroline)..

a few facts about Carmac just so you know your choosing the right ship:
1) Caroline has pretty much adored/loved Mac since the first episode.
2) Even some chavvy little kids could see that Caroline was the right one for Mac ('I think she's your one' or something to that effect)...you must know the episode I'm talking about, sue is giving a tour etc)
3) Guy only liked her this season, when she was emotionally unstable because of Holly messing with Mac etc......
4) Guy is a notorious bastard when it comes to women, he's loved caroline all of what, 2 minutes so he's bound to change is he?
5) MAC AND CAROLINE ARE DESTINED TO BE TOGETHER.
6) They've shared some amaznig kisses, some words....etc etc......He loves her more than Guy (Mac's look at Caroline at the housewarming party..

now, I'm trying to think of good things about Caroline and Guy.,....but there just aren't any its evil.!!!

JOIN THE FORCE AND SERVE MANKIND!!

titty_thomas - May 22, 2006 07:13 PM (GMT)
I've always been a Carmac shipper, beacuse it's what the writers have intended for us to think of as the "central" relationship, and because Mac is just so wonderfully fanciable and lovely. But in the last few episodes, the Guy and Caro stuff has been quite cool too, as it seems to be making them happy, plus Guy looks like an amaaazing kisser, which means their scenes are rather fun to watch, lol! (ok..i sound like a real perve there, :-S)

I'd still obvisouly prefer Carmac though....

m+cshipper - May 22, 2006 07:24 PM (GMT)
well obviously! haha
i do know what you mean though.

Ashleigh - May 22, 2006 07:29 PM (GMT)
I always thought I was carmac and I still do like them together but....Guy and Caroline has always sorta been there and its just...Guy is soo damn cute. lol

m+cshipper - May 22, 2006 07:31 PM (GMT)
do not stray!! haha..........your instincts are obvious towards CARMAC, let your instincts guide you! haha

hmmm I'd make an excellent teacher!

PigRescuer - May 22, 2006 07:31 PM (GMT)
caromac. it HAS to be. i'll (stealing someone else's idea) make dolls act it out for me if they dont. or better yet, force the actors to....

hmmmmmmmm

<wanders away to think>

but seriously, it has to be. iv been with them since the Look at the party.

caromac. caromac. caromac!

Ashleigh - May 22, 2006 07:38 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (m+cshipper @ May 22 2006, 07:31 PM)
do not stray!! haha..........your instincts are obvious towards CARMAC, let your instincts guide you! haha

hmmm I'd make an excellent teacher!

hahaha!!
Sorry...I've stepped onto the carguy side of the fence and the grass is greener :D :P

PigRescuer - May 22, 2006 08:05 PM (GMT)
<hisses>

as my signature says:

Mac is for life. Guy is just tilll christmas

SecretanFan - May 22, 2006 08:14 PM (GMT)
QUOTE
I've stepped onto the carguy side of the fence and the grass is greener


Too true!
Some points to bring you to OUR side :D :

1. As even Caroline says, there has always been something between them, ever since she stayed at his flat.
2. Their kisses have been so very much better than her and Mac's.
3. She accepted his proposal. :P
4. Mac is extremely irritating and cannot say anything serious to her unless it's a DAMN METAPHOR!
5. Guy got a tattoo for her.
6. Guy actually told her how he felt.
7. Guy's not dying.
8. Guy is generally just better.

Come on! G&C forever!

Lollapalooza - May 22, 2006 08:16 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (PigRescuer @ May 22 2006, 07:31 PM)
caromac. it HAS to be. i'll (stealing someone else's idea) make dolls act it out for me if they dont. or better yet, force the actors to....

hmmmmmmmm

<wanders away to think>

but seriously, it has to be. iv been with them since the Look at the party.

caromac. caromac. caromac!

haha stealing my idea and using it against me ay?


:P


but you all make good points, CarMac seem destined but Guy has just been so so so lovely lately.



ooohhh

kittyofdoom - May 22, 2006 08:30 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (SecretanFan @ May 22 2006, 08:14 PM)
7. Guy's not dying.

Hehe, that's a bit of a weak one, don't you think? :)

Well, compared to the others it had me laughing, as I am now sure Mac *isn't* dying, it's a bit like saying "Guy doesn't have ginger hair" or "Guy has four wheels not two".

Or maybe I'm just talking rubbish...

Lollapalooza - May 22, 2006 08:33 PM (GMT)
9. Guy doesnt kiss like a Newt

*makes kissy newt impressions at all CarMac-ers*




PigRescuer - May 22, 2006 08:36 PM (GMT)
MAC DOESNT KISS LIKE A NEWT

they kiss v cutely

and he times is perfectly. eg. the 'proper' kiss and the apology kiss

guy just lunges at her all the time

and remember the banana kiss is still to come.

SecretanFan - May 22, 2006 08:40 PM (GMT)
I know kitty, I was running out of ideas. :P

And yes, Mac does kiss like a newt. Newty newty newtyson. :D

Guy kisses like...oh I don't know, something that is a really good kisser. :wub:

Lollapalooza - May 22, 2006 08:43 PM (GMT)
pish pish Banana Kiss?


actually thinking about it CarGuy fans have a lot more to go on and look forawrd to than CarMac-ers'


Engagement Vs Bananary Kiss?


pfft


I can see which side of the fence my feet are dangleing

PigRescuer - May 22, 2006 08:45 PM (GMT)
at least we know tha banana kiss will definitly happen

yours could just fall to pieces.

=P

Lollapalooza - May 22, 2006 08:48 PM (GMT)
yeah well well well



PFFT


Guy and Caroline are sat next to each other at the funeral


so they obv don't hate each other by then meeeeaning .. *trails off*


well it means something!!!

PigRescuer - May 22, 2006 08:49 PM (GMT)
yes, and boyce and sue are also sitting next to each other. doe sthat mean theyre engaged?

Lollapalooza - May 22, 2006 08:50 PM (GMT)
oh pffft

shush you


you may well believe in this bananary kiss but who says it will be included?


and also maybe Macs last thing to eat before he dies is a banana and Caroline just kisses him as he dies.


AHHHH

PigRescuer - May 22, 2006 08:51 PM (GMT)
ah but no

because he apologises for the banana

and guy makes rude comments

which means they must.... um... hang on...

IMO - May 22, 2006 09:04 PM (GMT)
pfttt what a stupid question, obviously it's Caroline and Mac.

And Guy's idea of a relationship is a long term carpark, his idea of love is waking up in the night and.... what? (well we won't go there it's probably rude). And as for his tattoo, it's disappeared in a puff of smoke.

If anyone's sitting on the fence just look at my piccy down there v *winks* now there's passion, and she nearly falls over at the end. She didn't do that with Guy did she, nah nah nanaaaaaaaaaaaaaa.

m+cshipper - May 22, 2006 09:11 PM (GMT)
whoever said the grass was greener on the CarGuy side was severely disollusioned!! i've looked over there and the grass is brown and dying! no one waters it.....poor grass, it doesn't bode well for their relationship does it?! haha....

Guy's tatoo has disappeared strangely enough!! Hmm......
Caroline technically accepted Mac first, she went to the station to be wtih Mac NOT Guy, Guy is merely her second best.
Guy kisses like a newt on steroids who's currently on an LSD trip!! Ok, so the last two kisses weren't two bad, but both could not bring themselves to lean in for the kiss, so he basically attacked her!! And before that.......he looked like he couldn't decide what to do with his mouth!!

CarMac kisses are so much better, mainly because there is such a buildup to them and because there is a little thing called PASSION between them..


Oh dear, poor CarGuy shippers, you're in for a shock!!!

IMO - May 22, 2006 09:16 PM (GMT)
Guy does look like a good kisser - but it's all too calculated. Mac's kisses are unexpected, passionate and he makes Caroline go all wobbly on her legs.

Ashleigh - May 22, 2006 10:27 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (kittyofdoom @ May 22 2006, 08:30 PM)
"Guy has four wheels not two".

LMAO!!

Guy can't drive remember??? :P

and another thing for our side

Mac is always letting her down!!

newestgreenwingfan01 - May 23, 2006 05:09 AM (GMT)
QUOTE
Too true!
Some points to bring you to OUR side  :

1. As even Caroline says, there has always been something between them, ever since she stayed at his flat.
2. Their kisses have been so very much better than her and Mac's.
3. She accepted his proposal. 
4. Mac is extremely irritating and cannot say anything serious to her unless it's a DAMN METAPHOR!
5. Guy got a tattoo for her.
6. Guy actually told her how he felt.
7. Guy's not dying.
8. Guy is generally just better.

Come on! G&C forever!


plus guy looks like mr. darcy - macs just wickham!!!!!! GUY AND CAROLINE FOREVER!!!!!

Lollapalooza - May 23, 2006 08:30 AM (GMT)
I have to say these 5 words in Guys husky voice is probably what made me wonder about no more CarMac


''I love you Dr Todd''


so er when did Mac put his feeling on the line like that?


hmm people.



oh now I feel bad cos Mac just so yummy and well you are right about the whole passion thing.
and CarMac always seemed the destiny of like the whole entire program, the one storyline that seemed was going to end in the right way.



also Guy doesnt really look like a donkey.....oh no he reminds me of the blue ugly thing from the muppets....

user posted image
crap pic but the only one I could find.

and also how yummy did Mac's lips look when he was pouting after the marrige hola hoop convo on the bench?


mmmmmmmmmmmmmm

IMO - May 23, 2006 12:37 PM (GMT)
that's Gonzo :lol:

kittyofdoom - May 23, 2006 01:36 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (Ashleigh @ May 22 2006, 10:27 PM)
QUOTE (kittyofdoom @ May 22 2006, 08:30 PM)
"Guy has four wheels not two".

LMAO!!

Guy can't drive remember??? :P

and another thing for our side

Mac is always letting her down!!

Well, he *used* to, and when he did, he had four wheels. So um, there. Besides, it's irrelevant as Mac is aceness.

lora4dan - May 23, 2006 02:23 PM (GMT)
ok,lets do thisproperly.

Mac
____

Pro's: His mac-ness.
The way he kisses :wub:
His lions mane
The way he kisses
His morals
The way he kisses
Con's:He has never told her he loves her
His cruel streak(Swap shifts? :angry: )
His dumping of caro when holly appeared
His amnesia
Never knowing wot he wants
He's (mayb) dying
Guy
____

Pro's:He LOVES her. And has said and shown it
The way he kisses :heart
His marriage proposal
The way he kisses
His love making him a better man(alla as good as it gets)
The way he kisses
The way he walks out of train steam( :heart :heart :heart )
The way he kisses
Con's: His guy-ness
His lack of morals(Sometimes)
Throwing knives
Slept with his mother(accidently....)
His cruel streak
He's swiss

So,that makes it so much clearer then...... :swearing

titty_thomas - May 23, 2006 03:02 PM (GMT)
Lora4Dan, you forget to mention some crucial pro-Mac points:

1) He rides a motorbike, but seems like a safe person - helmets etc (apart from very end of last week, but that's understandable)
2) He appreciates the genius of the Kinks!!!!
3) He's lovely and tall (I have a thing for tall guys - not sure exactly why)
4) He'd make a really good dad - he wants what's best for Mackenzie, even though it means giving up what he wants most - Caroline.

Also, the coma, Holly coming back and the dying thing can't be counted as negatives - he couldn't help any of them. In fact, the coma was brought on by him trying to save the drunk and suicidal Guy.


I'm not saying Mac has no flaws - his need to cover true emotion with humour and analogies is really terrible for poor old Caroline (the eyebrow comment, anyone?) but he does have a lot of great points.

Just something to take into consideration, all those thinking of turning traitor....


lora4dan - May 23, 2006 03:23 PM (GMT)
ok i did forget he was lovely and tall :P


Ashleigh - May 23, 2006 10:06 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (lora4dan @ May 23 2006, 02:23 PM)
Mac
____

Pro's: His mac-ness.
The way he kisses :wub:
His lions mane
The way he kisses
His morals
The way he kisses
Con's:He has never told her he loves her
His cruel streak(Swap shifts? :angry: )
His dumping of caro when holly appeared
His amnesia
Never knowing wot he wants
He's (mayb) dying
Guy
____

Pro's:He LOVES her. And has said and shown it
The way he kisses :heart
His marriage proposal
The way he kisses
His love making him a better man(alla as good as it gets)
The way he kisses
The way he walks out of train steam( :heart :heart :heart )
The way he kisses
Con's: His guy-ness
His lack of morals(Sometimes)
Throwing knives
Slept with his mother(accidently....)
His cruel streak
He's swiss

So,that makes it so much clearer then...... :swearing

and after all of that we're back to square one !! lol.

I'm all for Guy and Caroline but Caroline and Mac isn't bad at all. :P

*debbie* - May 31, 2006 01:05 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (newestgreenwingfan01 @ May 23 2006, 05:09 AM)
QUOTE
Too true!
Some points to bring you to OUR side  :

1. As even Caroline says, there has always been something between them, ever since she stayed at his flat.
2. Their kisses have been so very much better than her and Mac's.
3. She accepted his proposal. 
4. Mac is extremely irritating and cannot say anything serious to her unless it's a DAMN METAPHOR!
5. Guy got a tattoo for her.
6. Guy actually told her how he felt.
7. Guy's not dying.
8. Guy is generally just better.

Come on! G&C forever!


plus guy looks like mr. darcy - macs just wickham!!!!!! GUY AND CAROLINE FOREVER!!!!!

NOOOO!
:angry: :angry: :angry:
its the other way round!!!
mac, like mr darcy, hides his feelings!
guy however has been telling caroline that he likes her, which is very wickham-like!
(ok, so wickham never SAID he liked Elizabeth, dosnt mean he didnt hint it!)

anyway, mac is for life, guys just till crimbo!
:P

madelinenancy - September 5, 2006 05:54 PM (GMT)
mac never lied or was sneaky jst to get her attention. AND he has the best cheekbones ever known to man.

also after much deliberation i have realised what Guy kisses like





THE ANSWER IS: A RUBBISH KISSER
:ooherr

SecretanFan - September 5, 2006 06:06 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (lora4dan @ May 23 2006, 02:23 PM)
Guy
____

Pro's:He LOVES her. And has said and shown it
The way he kisses :heart
His marriage proposal
The way he kisses
His love making him a better man(alla as good as it gets)
The way he kisses
The way he walks out of train steam( :heart :heart :heart )
The way he kisses
Con's: His guy-ness
His lack of morals(Sometimes)
Throwing knives
Slept with his mother(accidently....)
His cruel streak
He's swiss

You've put him being Swiss as a con!!! WTF? :o I love Swiss guys! :D

xjessx - September 6, 2006 03:01 PM (GMT)
GUY
.he loves her..and there is proff [he said so]
.he's a good kisser
.everykiss is special
.he's charming
.he's SWISS
.the look!
.funny
.fun in general
.ready to committ
.sexy
.good looking
.good taste in clothes
.up for a good time
.he has the best ass ever
.lovely hair

MAC
.he has the bike i want
.he likes the kinks too
.kinda cute

littlered - September 6, 2006 05:03 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (xjessx @ Sep 6 2006, 03:01 PM)
.kinda cute

"kinda"? "KINDA" Mac is lovely! He is incredibly cute, and you would do well to remember that. *shakes fist threateningly*




Hosted for free by InvisionFree