View Full Version: Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows

Green Wing Fan Forum > Chit Chat > Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows

Pages: [1] 2 3 4 57


Title: Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows
Description: For everyone who's done ...


littlered - July 21, 2007 09:38 PM (GMT)
I'm finished. I don't have a lot to say right now, partly because I'm a bit numb with shock (it's OVER. Over forever), and I just posted a lot on TNT, which covered a lot. Oh, but PR said to say that her theory was right (as was mine about the locket and Krecher and Mundungus, woot).
So, let the squeeing, or mourning, commence. To Harry Potter - the Boy who Lived.

newestgreenwingfan01 - July 22, 2007 07:58 AM (GMT)
I LOVED THIS BOOK!!!!!!!!

the ending was the cutest thing ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



:cry i didnt think id ever feel sorry for snape though!!!! now after reading the deathly hallows, what hes done in the other books is abruptly forgiven!!!

IMO - July 22, 2007 11:51 AM (GMT)
See I always knew Snape wasn't on the darkside :D otherwise why would Dumbledore have put so much faith in him.

Favorite section of the book is when they were back in Hogwarts, I also liked the bit with Dudley at the start, Krecher's change of heart towards Harry, aghhhh Page 502 :heart

but, but, but............ I want to know what careers Harry, Ron and Hermione took on, do we assume H and R both became Aurors :unsure: and I always saw Hermione as a Professor at Hogwarts. And did McGonall become the new Head :unsure:

enzotherhino - July 22, 2007 11:57 AM (GMT)
Yeah I'm glad Snape wasn't evil. But I was disappointed that we didn't find out people's jobs.

I loved Kreacher and I was so upset when Dobby died.

I didn't think Harry was going to be a horcrux cos i didnt see how she could get round killing voldemort after he was dead but I really liked how that worked.

Port-ahh Lover - July 22, 2007 02:41 PM (GMT)
As I am 1) too poor to buy DH, and 2) too lazy to read it, can someone please PM me the main points of the book, especially the ending and stuff.

pleeese?

QueenGW - July 22, 2007 03:04 PM (GMT)
lol i cnt blv ur not guna read it!! lol
loved it so much im reading it again atm
cnt blv its over tho im actually numb and i have cried a lot!!
cried when dobby died, it was so sad

and i was wel upset that lupin died as well i think him and tonks were the ones she wasnt guna kill off and then did

but i always thought snape was good and i was well happy cos i love snape! and i thought it was so cute with lily etc
and i love how everything fits together n makes sense now
i dunno how shes does it the plot is so intricate n she must have had it planned from day one bout the horcrxues etc cos of the diary
i cnt blv its over

best line in the book and it gets me every time:

'Albus Severus, youre named after two Hogwarts Headmasters. One of them was in Slytherin and he was probably the bravest man i've ever met'

here come the tears again!

newestgreenwingfan01 - July 22, 2007 03:23 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (QueenGW @ Jul 22 2007, 03:04 PM)
best line in the book and it gets me every time:

'Albus Severus, youre named after two Hogwarts Headmasters. One of them was in Slytherin and he was probably the bravest man i've ever met'

here come the tears again!

:cry i love that bit! it makes me cry!!!


JK knows how to switch peoples opinions! I never really disliked Snape but at the end of the Seventh i just forgave him completely!!!


and i love how Snape saved Harrys life time and time again and i love how harry names his son after him!!!


Although, just a mild afterthought, why does Harry name his kid after Snape? Snape never actually said he doesnt hate Harry, he just says hes protecting him cos of his love for Lily? Was the fact Snape protected him cos of the dead woman he loved enough to make Harry go: Actually Snape isnt a git after all?

littlered - July 22, 2007 03:36 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (Port-ahh Lover @ Jul 22 2007, 02:41 PM)
As I am 1) too poor to buy DH, and 2) too lazy to read it, can someone please PM me the main points of the book, especially the ending and stuff.

pleeese?

Charlotte! I know you're a spoiler whore, but you can't do that! It's madness!

xPL - July 22, 2007 03:59 PM (GMT)
Red, I NEED to know.

I cannot last until they release the audio, so I need to know.

pleeeese send me a run through?

*bats eyelashes*

littlered - July 22, 2007 04:02 PM (GMT)
Can't you go to the library or steal it from a friend or read it in the shop?
I can't give away spoilers, even if people ask for them. It's against my nature.

mini_marsbars_rule - July 22, 2007 05:56 PM (GMT)
Omg, best end to the series ever! I was saying to my dad just the other day that I thought JK couldn't win because if she had Hharry sacrifice himself, people would say it was cliché and if she had him survive and have a happy ending, they would say it was cheesy. But she actually pulled it off! Loved it.

I couldn't believe that it was only four chapters in and I already had tears in my eyes! Poor Hedwig and Mad-Eye! I definistely cried the most at Dobby's death and when Harry was walking towards death.

I did think that Draco would have been put to more use but the things he did, and Harry saving him were brilliant.

Everything was amazing though. Seriously the best book.

newestgreenwingfan01 - July 22, 2007 06:00 PM (GMT)
*couldnt agree with MMR more so cries 'Ear, 'Ear*

mini_marsbars_rule - July 22, 2007 06:03 PM (GMT)
Aww bless them, making jokes even though they've just been killed. But never again! :cry

newestgreenwingfan01 - July 22, 2007 06:05 PM (GMT)
everytime i think of some bits in the book i start crying!!! im gonna be one hysterically emotional girl in work tomorrow :P

enzotherhino - July 22, 2007 06:52 PM (GMT)
I just remembered something. If ron got splinched and never fixed (or did he and i missed that bit) then is there an arm just lying in the middle of the road?

QueenGW - July 22, 2007 06:58 PM (GMT)
i cried loads when dobby died it was rele sad
and i cried at the snape bits and the end

and the bit where dumbledore goes :even after all this time?
referring to snape loving lily and snape goes : Always.

thats my second favourite line

iv always loved snape!! ;lol

littlered - July 22, 2007 07:35 PM (GMT)
Does anyone else feel really bad now? It hurts that it's gone.

mini_marsbars_rule - July 22, 2007 08:46 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (littlered @ Jul 22 2007, 07:35 PM)
Does anyone else feel really bad now? It hurts that it's gone.

Yeah I know what you mean. Was watching Titanic earlier and the whole ending reminded me of HP when Jack comes to meet Rose when she dies. And also the song really fits HP too. Aww I'm gonna miss it so much.


oiyoupingpongman - July 23, 2007 01:19 AM (GMT)
Oh, im so devastated its all over. But yet ecstatically happy because HARRY SURVIVED. And yet J.K managed to please evrybody by killing him off, then brnging him back! Actually that really highlights the Messiah-ness (okay i could have put that better) of Harrys character, sacrificing himself to save the wizarding world, then coming back from the dead...

Why has nobody mentioned the horror of Fred dying? I think i actually screamed at that point! He was obviously the superior Weasley twin, and i thought, if they were going to kill off a Weasley, at least make it Percy. The git.

Am pleased theories about Good Snape and Harry The Horcrux were correct, as well as snape being in love with lily. Agree with IMO that we should have found out everyones jobs! Even if it had just been a list at the end of what happened to everyone!

I did think the book was a bit slow in the middle, when Ron left and it was just hermione and harry travelling about at random. And quite bleak at times (the implied rape of Adriana in particular) But my gods was it exciting at the beginning and end! Battle of Hogwarts was an especially inspired chapter!

Who's up for the adventures of Albus Severus Potter? I dont think that i can cope without anymore books!

littlered - July 23, 2007 04:58 AM (GMT)
There's already a huge fanfiction community dedicated to Albus Severus/Scorpio slash (known as AS/S). :lol:

mini_marsbars_rule - July 23, 2007 09:04 AM (GMT)
QUOTE (littlered @ Jul 23 2007, 04:58 AM)
There's already a huge fanfiction community dedicated to Albus Severus/Scorpio slash (known as AS/S).  :lol:

:lol: We couldn't have Draco & Harry together so we'll continue to dream through their children instead. Like father, like son eh? Still think I prefer H/D...

On another random note, did the Battle of Hogwarts remind anyone else of Beauy and the Beast? Because they were using everything they could from Mandrakes and Venemous Tentacula to suits of armour and ghosts and in B & the B they use allsorts like candlesticks and cutlery and what have you. Granted the things in B & the B were all alive, but then so were the suits of armour to an extent. I just loved Neville running past with Mandrakes ready to launch at the DE.

Random again, but you know how JK said that two people died who she didn't intend and one person got a reprieve, well who do you think they were? I think the two who died were Dobby and possibly Tonks and the reprieve was Harry. Because I was thinking about it last night, at the end of The Forest Again doesn't it feel like perhaps she intended Harry to die there but then changed her mind and wrote King's Cross instead? Or maybe not because then where would that leave everyone else who had to kill Nagini and Voldemort. Actually scratch that, I have no idea :P

Final random but was just thinking this morning, if they stay true to the book, Dan's gonna have to get his kit off again for King's Cross hehe. Actually does that mean he was naked in front of Dumbledore? Oh no, he'd found robes hadn't he? Ok I've got to stop backtracking because I'm pretty much talking to myself...

*debbie* - July 23, 2007 10:59 AM (GMT)
QUOTE (oiyoupingpongman @ Jul 23 2007, 01:19 AM)
Why has nobody mentioned the horror of Fred dying? I think i actually screamed at that point! He was obviously the superior Weasley twin, and i thought, if they were going to kill off a Weasley, at least make it Percy. The git.

wait, i thought he just lost an ear...
:unsure:
my sister stole the book at that point and i lost my place...

IMO - July 23, 2007 01:24 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (littlered @ Jul 23 2007, 05:58 AM)
There's already a huge fanfiction community dedicated to Albus Severus/Scorpio slash (known as AS/S). :lol:

Really that's quick :o

There has to be a book about Albus Serverus Potter :worship

newestgreenwingfan01 - July 23, 2007 05:54 PM (GMT)
the second generation!! lily and rose and hugo and albus and james!!! and scorpio naturally!!!! i hope JK succumbs to pressure and writes a book at the Marauders time at school! one half chapter of flashbacks was not enough for me - i wanted to read more of lily and james and snape and remus and sirius!!!

oiyoupingpongman - July 23, 2007 08:56 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (*debbie* @ Jul 23 2007, 11:59 AM)
QUOTE (oiyoupingpongman @ Jul 23 2007, 01:19 AM)
Why has nobody mentioned the horror of Fred dying? I think i actually screamed at that point! He was obviously the superior Weasley twin, and i thought, if they were going to kill off a Weasley, at least make it Percy. The git.

wait, i thought he just lost an ear...
:unsure:
my sister stole the book at that point and i lost my place...

No that was George who lost an ear, it was Fred who died.

After 3 hours of discussion in Cafe Nero (where all the best plans are laid) me and my friends have reached the conclusion that it was Lupin and Tonks who were supposed to live and Neville who was given a reprieve, as it looked likely that he would die killing a horcrux or Bellatrix Black at many points. Or perhaps Hagrid as we all thought hed died when falling off the motorbike, then when attacked by giant spiders...he had a lucky escape!

Theres AS/S slash? Must....seek!

Dr. Baroline Trodd - July 24, 2007 06:57 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (mini_marsbars_rule @ Jul 23 2007, 10:04 AM)


Random again, but you know how JK said that two people died who she didn't intend and one person got a reprieve, well who do you think they were? I think the two who died were Dobby and possibly Tonks and the reprieve was Harry. Because I was thinking about it last night, at the end of The Forest Again doesn't it feel like perhaps she intended Harry to die there but then changed her mind and wrote King's Cross instead? Or maybe not because then where would that leave everyone else who had to kill Nagini and Voldemort. Actually scratch that, I have no idea :P


I personally thought it was Lupin and Tonks who werethe two killed off at late notice, as they were a pair and also their deaths were referred to very quickly and with no detail. This upset me a bit, actually, as the book had already mildly implied Lupin's cowardice in running from Tonks' pregnancy, I felt he deserved at least a detailed and tear-jerking death scene.

The reprieve I think must have been someone who had a later role in the novel that she had to keep them to fulfil, but because we don't know when the person was meant to die, who knows lol Perhaps Luna?

I want to know the chapter where JKR bawled her eyes out - Harryw alking to his death maybe?

QueenGW - July 24, 2007 10:15 PM (GMT)
i think it was lupin and tonks as well
i still cant believe lupin died

and maybe hagrid who got let off cos i reckoned he was going to die

im soo up for remus sirius snape james etc times at school that wud be great

not so sure bout albus severus........be hard to not make it repetitve! lol i dunno tho

QueenGW - July 25, 2007 11:03 AM (GMT)
OMG THIS IS AWESOME everyone click on the link below

it may not be the last we know of harry etc

clickety click

Dr. Baroline Trodd - July 25, 2007 12:49 PM (GMT)
I just saw that on Mugglenet - Arthur Weasley got his reprieve then :)

enzotherhino - July 25, 2007 12:55 PM (GMT)
roflmao :roflmao

http://www.fanfiction.net/s/3678015/1/The_...ing_Hat_Is_Evil

AS/S spoof.

and yey for the new book - i was hoping she would do that

mini_marsbars_rule - July 25, 2007 05:38 PM (GMT)
Thanks for those links guys. I think I agree with JK that the bit where Harry is walking to Voldemort is my favourite part of the whole series, but I also really hate it cuz I know I'll never be able to read it without crying :P

:lol: That fic is possibly the most random thing I've ever read. It's wonderful hehe.

XTinker_Bellx - July 25, 2007 08:54 PM (GMT)
Finally got around to finishing it! And Omg!! What a book!!

It's made me feel pretty much every emotion there is to feel! I've cried, Laughed, screamed, fallen on the floor in shock..it's all been there!!

Okay right..

*happy dance* My theory was right!! I said all along that Harry was a horcrux and would have to sacrifice himself but he wouldn't die!! I said it all along and I'm right!! That never happens!! I was so shocked I fell over!!

Dudley! Omg Dudley shocked me aswell! I never in a million years thought that Dudley Dursley would miss Harry!! Never!! I thought it was the sweetest thing!! Good old Dudders!!

Dumbledore - I always adored Dumbledore..thought he was an utter legend..but in this book I doubted my judgement..I mean yeah okay so he can't have always been a saint but well after the stories came out about the neglect of his sister and his friendship with grindelwald..yeah doubted him a bit. And then of course when we saw him in the pensieve..was utterly furious with him..using Harry as a tool..I mean god I felt betrayed!! But then of course Dumbledore appears at Kings cross and isn't a bad naughty betrayer at all..he's still an utter legend and well I love him ^_^

Snape - I never saw that coming..kinda thought he had a crush on lily..but the whole Good!Snape thing scared me a bit. I never actually liked him..I thought he was funny at times but I thought he was a git..and of course despised him after he killed dumbledore..but after the pensieve..well actually in the shrieking Shack..well my opinion changed okay. To think that Dumbledore knew he was dying..to ask Snape to kill him..to know that Snape loved Lily and protected Harry out of his love for her..that guy is truly brave, and so misunderstood! I take back everything I said..

Neville - I adore that guy, always have done and I'm damn happy he's found himself!!

I cried like hell when Dobby died! It was horrible! And all in the act of saving Harry Potter! Although I reckon that's how he'd have wanted to go because he worshipped Harry but y'know..it was still heartbreaking!!

Fred! I was annoyed that they killed Fred! Annoyed and utterly upset! Fred was the bestest of the Weasleys!! The bestest!! And they killed him!! Bastards!! And George..I've never laughed so much at someone losing their ear!! Those two are utter legends!!

Lupin..I cried that he died! Especially after his and harry's argument..and then him being all happy and telling harry that he's gunna be godfather to Teddy..I do think though that Tonks and Lupin shouldhave had their own scene..they deserved that much..a proper glorified heros death..y'know is that too much to ask for?

As for Ron walking out on Harry..I think we all knew that was gunna happen didn't we..Ron doesn't like it when he doesn't know whats going on does he..but he came back and he was good ^_^ bless him, and hermione snogging in the middle of war though..such pleebs!!

cried buckets at harry going off to die..I thought it would happen but it still didn't make it easier..especially with his parents, sirius and lupin following him..it was way too sad!! And then afterwards..everyones reaction to Harry's 'death'..kinda felt for Narcissa aswell I know she's a bitch but still..

Dunno why but my admiration of McGonigall totally increased..she's just awesome!!

Was anyone else slightly confused as to Voldermorts death..it goes on about the sun..then harry catchin the wand and suddenly voldermorts dead..had to go over it again to get it..

As for the bit where they go up to Dumbledore's office after Voldermort dies and Dumbledore's all happy and stuff..cried again lol.

But I do wanna know what exactly happened during the 19 years that passed..what they did..and all that..still

Albus Severus..total cutie huh!! I adored the line about Snape being one of the bravest wizards harry knew..it was just so cute!!

Yes..so..loved the book.







mini_marsbars_rule - July 26, 2007 03:29 PM (GMT)
So Tinks, did you like it? :P

Dr. Baroline Trodd - July 26, 2007 08:43 PM (GMT)
QUOTE
bless him, and hermione snogging in the middle of war though..such pleebs!!


I thought that was cute... lol

I only realised today that the reason Harry didn't die was because he had all three deathly hallows!

XTinker_Bellx - July 26, 2007 09:06 PM (GMT)
I did indeed MMR!!

Lol it was cute..bless em!

oiyoupingpongman - July 26, 2007 10:08 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (Dr. Baroline Trodd @ Jul 26 2007, 09:43 PM)
QUOTE
bless him, and hermione snogging in the middle of war though..such pleebs!!


I thought that was cute... lol

I only realised today that the reason Harry didn't die was because he had all three deathly hallows!

Oh! *lightbulb pings on over head*

But that...cant be right can it? because in the forest he didnt have voldys wand, and when harry eventualy did win the wand he was back in hogwarts and had dropped the ring in the forest?

So i still dont understand how harry didnt die! Must read again...

The sorting hat on facebook just sorted me into Ravenclaw *feels proud* Its Lunas house and Luna is a legend :)

Dr. Baroline Trodd - July 26, 2007 10:10 PM (GMT)
Yeah but I thought he just had to be the rightful owner of all three?

oiyoupingpongman - July 26, 2007 10:16 PM (GMT)
Oh i thought they had to be put together in the pattern thing....i was expecting that to happen! And then create A RIFT BETWEEN THE WORLD OF LIVING AND DEAD THAT SIRIUS COULD CROSS BACK OVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

little bit excited there..

XTinker_Bellx - July 27, 2007 12:13 AM (GMT)
I think it was the act of sacrificing himself for the greater good that sayed Harry..in other words the famous ability to love..

But then Maybe it was the fact that He had two parts of soul in his body..not both his but the killing curse only destroyed the one part leaving his soul intact and keeping him alive?

I dunno

QueenGW - July 27, 2007 10:50 AM (GMT)
harry did have all three, cos he had the cloak, the stone, and you know malfoy had the elder wand (well had mastery over it) because he was the one who took dumbledores wand away from him, so when harry took malfoys wand at malfoy manor, harry gained mastery over it
if that makes any sense
so even tho voldemort had the actualy physical wand, he wasnt its master

therefore harry had all hallows so did not die! :D




Hosted for free by InvisionFree