Hi, Unicorn... and welcome to the CloudxAerith forums! :D
First of all, please see our
Forum Rules. The members of this forum are
against the idea of Cloud loving Tifa. This is a CloudxAerith forum, and we
only agree with the idea of Cloud loving Aerith.
The idea of Cloud loving Tifa is discussed on many other forums. If you want to talk about why Cloud loving Tifa might be correct, then please go to another forum to do that. We don't allow that here to avoid big arguments with people who disagree with us. This forum
only talks about why we think Cloud loved Aerith.
But here is a quick summary:
People who think Cloud loved Tifa think that Cloud had a crush on Tifa when he was young. They think that the scene where Tifa forces Cloud to make a Promise at the Well is a very romantic scene. They think that Cloud and Tifa have been in love since they were children. They think that Cloud forgot his love for Tifa in Disk One because they think that Cloud thought he was Zack during Disk One. They believe that Cloud didn't remember his love for Tifa until the Lifestream Event, when he got his memories back. They think that Cloud and Tifa made love under the Highwind, and told each other how much they loved one another at that time. They think that Cloud only wanted to meet Aerith at the end of the game to thank her, and that Cloud's true love was Tifa.
The members of this forum do not agree with any of these ideas. If you look through our
Evidence Against Cloud and Tifa, you'll find out
why we don't agree.